Chapter 4: From Thesis to Essay
Self-Evaluation of Your Three-Storey Thesis
Taking Measure
Each question requires a “Yes” or “No” answer. For each “Yes” response, give yourself one point. Your final score will be mark out of twenty-three (ex: Twenty-one “Yes” responses = 21/23).
Components
Did you identify a specific audience? (Who? Where? When?)
Y/N
Did you identify two specific pieces of evidence?
Y/N
Did you identify a central aspect or element?
Y/N
Did you make YOUR claim about the AUTHOR’S purpose? Is it a statement with which one could agree or disagree?
Y/N
Is there a unique third storey that concludes your thesis? Is it different than the second storey?
Y/N
Are each of your three storeys roughly equal in length?
Y/N
First Storey: Evidence/Observations
Is the first piece of evidence something you can literally point to the text?
Y/N
Is the second piece of evidence something you can literally point to the text?
Y/N
Does each of piece of evidence add something new? Are they different from each other?
Y/N
Is your evidence rich in connotative value? Do the words potentially have multiple meanings?
Y/N
Second Storey: Argument
Have you focused on the AUTHOR’S argument? You should not be voicing your opinion on the author’s topic.
Y/N
Does your proposed analysis of the author’s argument follow from the evidence provided?
Y/N
Is your proposed analysis complex? Does it take you more than half a sentence to describe it?
Y/N
Does your proposed analysis of the author’s argument utilize strong and precise language?
Y/N
Third Storey: A Full Complex Argument
Does your third storey follow logically from the second storey?
Y/N
Does your third storey clarify the second storey by adding something new?
Y/N
Does your third storey consider the results and consequences of the sort of analysis proposed in the second storey?
Y/N
Does your third storey use keywords or phrases from the text to add something new to the second storey?
Y/N
Is your third storey still focused on the author’s complex argument? You want to be sure that you have not strayed into your own unanalytical discussion of the author’s subject.
Y/N
Style
Did you use strong verbs throughout your thesis?
Y/N
Did the level of language reflect the tone of the author’s argument?
Y/N
Did you avoid the use of first-person pronouns? (“I,” “we,” “us,” “our,” etc.)
Y/N
Did you avoid words from the Ctrl-F list? (“society,” “technology,” “people,” etc.)
Y/N